letter to the NYS Senate's Task Force
on Lyme and Tick Borne Disease
Empire State Lyme Disease Association, Inc
Contact: Eva Haughie PO Box 874 Manorville, NY 11949 631-878-6657 or
In 1988 only five doctors told me that I didn’t have Lyme until I was diagnosed.
From 1987 to 1989, my mother believed that she had a nervous breakdown until she
was finally diagnosed. Yet, I don’t feel that there was as much denying of Lyme
then as there was ignorance of Lyme.
Later on, ignorance became denial and truth became hard to find as the
scientific feud between the Infectious Diseases Society of America and the
International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society raged on.
Does a scientific feud explain what has happened and why so many people have
been left to suffer and yes, die?
An IDSA doctor once admitted that he would lose his NIH funding if he reported
too many positive Lyme disease test results. If what the IDSA doctor said is
true, what would justify saying a positive test result is negative? There’s no
understanding this at all.
Obviously truth is especially important to Lyme patients. Many times, we learn
something new that overrides old truth, like what you were told was all in your
mind is really a plethora of tick-borne infections or like your negative test
result was really positive. (Which happened at the university where the doctor
mentioned above worked; we know several patients who were told they had negative
test results and they later found the results were definitely positive. My
daughter was a victim of Lyme and also a victim of being told her test result
was negative when it was truly positive.)
Truth, ethical behavior, moral values, moral code, principles should be
especially foremost in science. There have been numerous articles about ethics
in science going awry. Why have our researchers been blacklisted? Why would
anyone want the number of reported positive blood test results kept to a
falsified low number? Why has our good science been rejected, ignored, and
One reason is that IDSA is in control. A few brave individuals have switched
sides but think about it, if our side is correct, and if the other side knows
it, then most of them are simply too cowardly to admit the truth. You could have
sympathy for them, as they could face ruination, lose all credibility, be sued,
and lose their practices, if they told the truth. No sympathy? Well at least it
is easier to see why they have to fight us. And fight they do, for how can a
multi-award winning film documentary like Under Our Skin receive anything but
rave reviews? If you want to be shocked, read what the ALDF and others wrote
about it. Then think again, of how much is at stake if they admit the truth.
There are 14 IDSA Lyme guideline authors. A quote from their website: “Today,
IDSA is no longer a small, elite group, but a large and growing Society (of)
9,000 plus members.” (Lyme organizations’ membership is over 150,000 members)
Consider the fourteen IDSA Lyme guideline authors in proportion to their own
members, these 14 only comprise 0.156 percent of the IDSA membership.
From “A Census of Actively Licensed Physicians in the United States, 2012” the
number of licensed physicians in the US is 878,194. IDSA membership is 9000. If
you divide 9000 by 878,194, you get 0.01025. Or, the IDSA represents only 1
percent of all US doctors! And think: the 14 guideline authors comprise a measly
0.002 percent of all US physicians! (0.002 percent can be stated as two one
thousandths of a percent!)
There are between 10.000.000 - 15.000.000 (ten million to fifteen million)
doctors in the world. (http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_doctors_are_in_the_world)
The 9000 IDSA members divided by the lower number of 10million = .0009 which
means that the total IDSA membership comprises 0.09 percent of the world’s
doctors. If you do the math for the 14 guideline authors, the number is
negligible, that is these 14 can be considered as zero percent of the world’s
Yet these 14 dictate diagnosis and treatment of Lyme disease. These piddling 14
are dictating to the entire world’s population! NY has one of the highest
numbers of reported cases. The suffering here in NY, as across the world, is
terrible beyond description. And what is wrong with the CDC, etc, that they
religiously follow this piddling small amount of the world’s scientists and
doctors? Is the problem that Lyme is big business? Big business is usually
controlled by a small number of people. That’s okay if those in control are
correct and also tell the truth.